top of page

ABOUT US

Reindeer.jpg

BLOG

A World Language Advancement and Readiness Program (WLARP) project looks very different in Year 1 than it does in Year 5. Early on, districts hire teachers, adopt curriculum, and recruit families. In the middle years, attention turns to student proficiency and to showing families and school boards that the program works. By the final years of the project, the focus shifts to keeping the program running after the grant ends.


As a project’s needs change, its evaluation should change with it. That is why Shaffer Evaluation Group (SEG) created an add-on menu for our Department of War Education Activity (DoWEA) evaluation plans. Districts choose the add-ons that fit each stage of their project, from early feedback on implementation to planning for sustainability. This post walks through how a WLARP project could use those evaluation add-ons to meet its needs throughout the grant.


How the Add-On Menu Works

Every SEG evaluation plan for DoWEA grants meets the core requirements: annual monitoring of student outcomes, the annual performance report, and the final closeout report. Our Enhanced plan includes one add-on per year, and our Comprehensive plan includes two. Districts choose their add-ons each year, so the evaluation can change as the project changes.


The menu includes 10 add-ons in three categories:

  • Communicating results: a slide deck, a one-page infographic summary, a virtual board or leadership presentation, and success story profiles.

  • Using results: a sensemaking session, a data walk, and a sustainability planning session.

  • Deeper analysis and support: advanced statistical analysis, an extra site visit day, and a next-opportunity brainstorming session.


Most add-ons are “light” and fit any budget within the plan. A few are “extended” and may need a budget toward the upper end of the plan’s range. Below, we follow a sample WLARP project through the life of its grant to show how the choices might change from year to year.


Year 1: Getting the Program Off the Ground

Our sample district is launching a Spanish immersion program in its elementary schools that serve many military-connected families. It chose a Comprehensive plan, so it selects two add-ons each year. In the first year, the district’s main question is whether the program is running the way it was designed.


An extra site visit day helps answer that question. The evaluator can observe more immersion classrooms and hold focus groups with teachers and families. Teachers can describe what is working with the new curriculum, and families can share why they enrolled and what concerns they have. These early insights are hard to gather through surveys alone.


A sensemaking session helps the team act on what the evaluator finds. In this facilitated meeting, the project team and the evaluator review first-year data together and agree on next steps. For example, the team might notice that teachers want more planning time for content taught in Spanish and decide to adjust the professional learning schedule. Making those changes early keeps small problems from growing over the life of the grant.


Year 2: Answering Families’ Questions About English and Math

After the first year of implementation, a new need surfaced. Some parents worried that learning in Spanish would cause their children’s English reading and math scores to fall. This concern is common in immersion programs, and it can affect whether families enroll or stay. Families want to know what is happening in their own schools.


Advanced statistical analysis can answer that question with the district’s own data. A simple comparison of immersion and non-immersion students can mislead, because families who choose immersion may differ from those who do not. Instead, the evaluator can compare immersion students with similar students who had the same starting scores, track each group’s growth over time, and report results for subgroups such as military-connected students and English learners. Because military-connected students often move between schools, the analysis can also account for how long each student has been in the program. This is an extended add-on, so it may require a budget toward the upper end of the plan’s range.


A one-page infographic summary puts those results in the hands of families. The evaluator turns the analysis into a short visual summary that parents can read in a few minutes. The district can share it at enrollment nights, school board meetings, and with installation school liaison officers who support military families. Clear, local evidence helps families make enrollment decisions based on data instead of worry.


Years 3 and 4: Using Results Across Grade Levels

By Year 3, the program has proficiency data from several grade levels, and teachers need a way to use it together. A data walk meets that need. During a data walk, teachers and school leaders review posted results together, talk about what they see, and decide what to adjust (Murray et al., 2015). Immersion teachers compare proficiency results across grades and plan how to strengthen the hand-off from one grade to the next. A data walk takes more time to prepare and facilitate, so it is an extended add-on. 


A board or leadership presentation keeps district leaders informed as the program grows. The evaluator presents results virtually and answers questions, so leaders hear the findings directly. This builds the support the program will need when decisions about local funding come up in the final years.


Years 4 and 5: Planning for What Comes Next

In the final years, the district’s biggest question is how to keep the program going once grant funding ends. A sustainability planning session uses the project’s own data to guide that work. The team can review which program parts produced the strongest results, what they cost, and which ones the district can maintain with local funds. For an immersion program, the session might focus on keeping a steady supply of qualified teachers and continuing the pathway into middle and high school.


Success story profiles capture the program’s impact in a form that numbers alone cannot. These short stories might describe a student who kept learning Spanish after a family move, or a teacher who changed how she teaches content in two languages. Districts can share the profiles with families and community partners and include them in the final closeout report.


A next-opportunity brainstorming session helps the district plan for future funding. The evaluator and project team identify other grants the district could pursue and the data from the current grant that would strengthen those applications. A district with five years of proficiency and implementation data has a strong case to make to its next funder.


Evaluation Support That Grows With Your Project

The table below summarizes how our sample district might choose its two add-ons each year. A district with an Enhanced plan would choose one add-on per year, starting with the one that best fits that year’s main question.

Grant year 

Project need 

Sample add-ons 

Year 1 

Is the program running as designed? 

Extra site visit day; sensemaking session 

Year 2 

Are students’ English and math scores holding steady? 

Advanced statistical analysis; one-page infographic summary 

Year 3 

How can teachers use proficiency results across grade levels? 

Data walk; board or leadership presentation 

Year 4 

What should continue after the grant ends? 

Sustainability planning session; success story profiles 

Year 5 

How do we keep the program going and fund what comes next? 

Sustainability planning session; next-opportunity brainstorming session 

Every WLARP project has different needs, and those needs change over five years. The add-on menu lets districts direct their evaluation budget to the support that matters most at each stage, from early implementation feedback to sustainability planning. Not sure which plan or add-ons fit your project? Tell us your award amount and district location, and we will recommend a plan within your evaluation budget. Contact us at seg@shafferevaluation.com or 833-650-EVAL (3825), or visit our DoWEA evaluation services page.


References

Murray, B., Falkenburger, E., & Saxena, P. (2015). Data walks: An innovative way to share data with communities. Urban Institute. https://www.urban.org/research/publication/data-walks-innovative-way-share-data-communities


Teacher shows an ASUSTADO card to laughing preschoolers in a colorful Spanish classroom with alphabet and color posters.

The Department of Education recently announced the FY 2026 Title III Strengthening Institutions Program awards, and they offer a revealing look at how colleges and universities are responding to the pressures facing higher education.


A review of 384 funded-project abstracts shows institutions building connected systems intended to help students enter college, persist, complete meaningful credentials, and move into further education or employment. Career pathways, artificial intelligence, rural access, advising, institutional data, faculty development, and sustainability repeatedly intersect across the projects.


Although every institution begins with its own students, community, and capacity challenges, six major themes stand out across the funded projects.


1. Student success is becoming an institution-wide system

Advising, coaching, tutoring, early alerts, peer mentoring, and academic planning appear throughout the funded projects. What is significant is how often institutions are bringing these services together.


Rather than asking students to navigate a collection of disconnected offices, many projects propose centralized success centers, coordinated advising teams, case-management models, and technology that helps staff recognize when a student may need assistance. Several institutions plan to reduce advisor caseloads, provide more proactive outreach, and support students through critical transition points such as the first year, transfer, and entry into upper-level coursework.


The underlying idea is straightforward: retention and completion improve when support is timely, coordinated, and sustained.


Projects also frequently target students who have historically faced barriers to completion, including first-generation and low-income students, rural learners, adult students, and students entering through transfer or dual-enrollment pathways. The emphasis is not simply on expanding access but on building the institutional capacity required to help students finish.


2. Career preparation is moving into the center of the college experience

Career pathways and workforce readiness constitute one of the strongest themes in the FY 2026 cohort. In our thematic review, 165 projects, or approximately 43 percent of the awards, explicitly referenced the federal competitive preference priority related to career pathways and workforce readiness.


Institutions are responding by embedding career exploration, industry-recognized credentials, internships, clinical placements, practicums, and other forms of work-based learning into academic programs. Employer advisory groups and formal industry partnerships are also common, particularly in healthcare, advanced manufacturing, skilled trades, information technology, education, aerospace, clean energy, and other fields experiencing regional labor shortages.


This represents an important shift. Career preparation is increasingly being designed as part of the academic experience rather than as an optional service students encounter near graduation. Projects are connecting coursework, credentials, advising, and employer engagement so that students can see where their programs lead and what they need to do next.


3. Short-term and stackable credentials are expanding pathways to opportunity

More than half of the abstracts refer to certificates, credentials, or short-term programs. A smaller but distinct group of 21 projects explicitly addresses the Workforce Pell competitive preference priority.


These projects are developing or redesigning short, credit-bearing programs that can lead quickly to employment while also connecting to longer-term certificates and degrees. Many include new laboratory equipment, flexible scheduling, certification preparation, employer-informed curricula, and systems for tracking completion, employment, and earnings.


The most promising approaches treat short-term credentials as on-ramps rather than endpoints. A student may begin with a focused credential, enter the workforce, and later apply that learning toward an associate or bachelor’s degree. This stackable model can make higher education more responsive to working adults and other students who cannot commit immediately to a multiyear program.


4. Artificial intelligence is becoming practical infrastructure

Artificial intelligence is another defining feature of the FY 2026 portfolio. Approximately 32 percent of projects explicitly reference the competitive preference priority for artificial intelligence in education, while many additional abstracts mention AI-related activities.

The projects generally focus on practical applications rather than technology for its own sake. Proposed uses include:


  • Integrating responsible AI literacy into courses and credentials

  • Redesigning gateway courses with AI-supported learning tools

  • Offering personalized academic or career assistance

  • Strengthening early-alert and advising systems

  • Preparing faculty and staff to use AI appropriately

  • Helping students understand how AI is changing their future professions


Several institutions also pair AI implementation with faculty development, digital-equity measures, data governance, or upgraded technology infrastructure. This suggests an emerging recognition that adopting AI requires more than purchasing a tool. Institutions must also build the human expertise, policies, access, and evidence needed to use it responsibly.


5. Rural institutions are designing around place

Approximately 32 percent of the funded projects explicitly identify the competitive preference priority for rural institutions. Rural needs also appear in many other abstracts.


These projects reflect challenges that are particularly acute in geographically dispersed communities: limited access to college programs, shortages of healthcare and education professionals, fewer local employers, transportation barriers, aging facilities, and constrained institutional resources.


The proposed responses are highly place-based. Colleges are developing programs around local workforce needs, expanding hybrid and distance-learning capacity, modernizing laboratories, strengthening high school and community partnerships, and creating pathways into occupations that are essential to their regions.


For rural-serving institutions, capacity building is inseparable from community development. A new nursing, teaching, technical, or workforce program can strengthen both the institution and the surrounding region.


6. Institutional capacity includes people, facilities, data, and sustainability

The abstracts make clear that lasting institutional change requires several forms of capacity.


Many projects combine new or improved academic programs with renovated facilities, laboratories, simulation environments, instructional equipment, student-success technology, and stronger data systems. Faculty and staff professional development is another recurring investment, especially where institutions are redesigning courses, adopting AI, or expanding career-connected learning.


Sustainability is also built into many project designs. Institutions propose developing endowments, aligning programs with performance-based funding, generating enrollment revenue, securing employer support, and incorporating grant-funded roles or practices into regular operations. This is important because a successful Title III project should leave behind more than a collection of completed activities. Its systems, expertise, partnerships, and evidence should continue strengthening the institution after federal funding ends.


What these Title III projects mean for evaluation

The breadth of the FY 2026 projects creates both an opportunity and an evaluation challenge. A single initiative may simultaneously involve curriculum redesign, advising, faculty development, employer partnerships, technology implementation, facility upgrades, credentials, and student outcomes.


Shaffer Evaluation Group (SEG) helps colleges and universities develop practical evaluation plans, logic models, performance measures, data-collection strategies, continuous-improvement processes, and clear reports for Title III initiatives. SEG has experience supporting community colleges and universities with Title III grant development and external evaluation, including projects focused on student success, institutional capacity, workforce programs, and underserved learners. Learn more about SEG’s Title III grant evaluation services.


Four college students sit on grass outdoors, smiling and talking with notebooks and bags between them on a campus lawn.

What happens when creativity meets opportunity? Across the country, community-based youth arts programs are showing us. These programs not only nurture artistic skills but also create paid work opportunities, positioning young people for brighter futures.


Inspiring these efforts is a powerful question: how can the arts help young people build both bonding and bridging social capital—the supportive relationships and wider networks that open doors to economic mobility?


Youth Arts Programs as a Foundation for Skill-Building

Some programs put the arts at the center of their workforce approach. They emphasize hard and soft skill development—teaching young people how to collaborate, problem-solve, and communicate effectively, while also mastering artistic techniques and tools.


Take DCTV Youth Media in New York City. This program trains teenagers and young adults (ages 13–24) to use media as a tool for storytelling and social change. Participants learn the ins and outs of filmmaking—from planning and production to editing—but the learning goes far deeper. Collaboration, critical thinking, and creative expression are woven into the experience, helping young people cultivate confidence and a sense of belonging.


Arts as a Gateway to Professional Networks

Other programs act as brokers, connecting youth directly to professional environments where they can explore careers, build networks, and gain real-world work experience.


The Bloomberg Arts Internship (BAI) is a standout example. Launched in New York City in 2012, BAI provides public high school students with paid internships in arts and cultural institutions. Students gain both technical and soft skills while experiencing firsthand how the arts sector operates. The program’s success has led to expansions in Philadelphia, Baltimore, Boston, Detroit, and Washington, DC—helping thousands of young people connect with mentors, colleagues, and future career opportunities.


Why Social Capital Matters

These two models—arts-centered skill-building and brokering workplace opportunities—share a common thread: they help young people expand their social capital in two ways:

  • Bonding capital emerges when youth form close, supportive relationships through collaborative art-making. Research shows that creative youth development (CYD) programs foster belonging, identity, and emotional well-being.

  • Bridging capital arises when young people connect to broader networks across social and economic boundaries. For marginalized youth especially, these connections are essential for career readiness and long-term mobility—but often harder to access without structured opportunities like internships and apprenticeships.


By intentionally designing programs that combine both bonding and bridging experiences, community-based arts initiatives can play a transformative role in equity and opportunity.


What We Still Need to Learn

While research underscores the many benefits of arts engagement—creativity, collaboration, resilience—important gaps remain. We know less about how programs can best integrate paid work experiences to maximize bridging capital and long-term impact.


A systematic effort to map the field could clarify how programs structure their workforce components, support teaching artists as mentors, and sustain operations through partnerships and funding. These insights would strengthen the sector and provide a roadmap for future investment and program design.


Looking Ahead

The intersection of arts and workforce development is more than just a program design—it’s a philosophy. By aligning artistic growth with professional opportunity, these programs empower young people to see themselves not only as creators but also as future leaders, collaborators, and change-makers.


Community-based youth arts programs that integrate paid work opportunities have the potential to transform lives. By building both strong communities and wide-open pathways to opportunity, they show us what’s possible when creativity is paired with meaningful work.



👉 At ArtsInSight, we’ll continue to spotlight how the arts open doors for young people and strengthen communities, helping programs design with both artistry and opportunity in mind.


Anchor 1

Shaffer Evaluation Group

5388 Discovery Park Blvd, Suite 220

Williamsburg, VA 23188   

833.650.3825

 

© Shaffer Evaluation Group LLC 2026 

bottom of page